Defending penal substitutionary atonement evidence unseen. It developed with the reformed tradition as a specific understanding. The first a matter of systematic theology is that despite the sustained scholarly and subscholarly onslaught against the doctrine of penal substitutionary atonement in recent years the idea remains intact. First part makes the case for penal substitutionary atonement 21204 and the second part answers the critics of the espoused view of the authors 205328. Penalsubstitutionary atonement in church history reformed. Historical reflections on substitutionary atonement. Wolfhart pannenberg is known for many elements of his theologyeschatology, history, the resurrection, the trinitybut i rarely see him brought up in discussions of the atonement. So, penal substitution is the act of a person taking the punishment for someone elses offenses. In it, he explores the relationship between penal substitutionary atonement psa.
I use it because the web is in the public domain not ed. Steve jeffery, michael ovey, and andrew sach, pierced for our transgressions. In this new episode of theology refresh, we were privileged to talk with jarvis williams, associate professor. Steve jeffery, michael ovey, and andrew sach, the authors of the recent book rediscovering the glory of penal substitution, claim that penal substitutionary theory stretches back to the earliest fathers of the church. Greg boyd outlines the penal substitution view of atonement and some of the problems this view creates. Rediscovering the glory of penal substitution, forward by john piper wheaton, ill crossway books, 2007, p.
He is dealing with what he calls caricatures of the cross, correcting so many bad arguments against penal substitutionary atonement by pointing out that they are based on misunderstandings of the doctrine as well as. May 25, 2016 wolfhart pannenbergs historical penal substitutionary atonement wolfhart pannenberg is known for many elements of his theologyeschatology, history, the resurrection, the trinitybut i rarely see him brought up in discussions of the atonement. Wolfhart pannenbergs historical penal substitutionary. Its a theory which i have argued against openly and often, ive written extensively against it in my book we belong.
Penal substitutionary atonement is a theory about how the gospel works. Why i have changed my mind about penal substitution union. In particular, the book offers background to the current debates about penal substitutionary atonement by looking at that idea in biblical and historical perspective. Jan 02, 2020 so, penal substitution is the act of a person taking the punishment for someone elses offenses. Throughout the history of christian doctrine, the cross of christ has proved to be a magnet for. Penal substitutionary atonement and concern for suffering. Simon gathercole, reader in new testament studies, university of cambridge the theological glue that holds the gospel facts together is the substitutionary atonement of jesus christ. Sep 11, 2012 ill come clean and say that im a huge n. Jeffrey johns as well as a recent book on the subject. It argues that christ, by his own sacrificial choice, was punished penalised in the place of sinners substitution, thus satisfying the. Atonement and penal substitution in the bible and history london. Throughout my 63 years as an evangelical believer, the penal substitutionary understand. Swinburnian atonement and the doctrine of penal substitution.
The first part begins with presenting the case biblically 3399, theologically 100148, pastorally 149160, and historically 161204. Jul 08, 2017 making god bound by necessity the heretical doctrine of penal substitution was completely absent from the church for over 1,000 years, and was only introduced by anselm of canterbury in the eleventh century. Unless otherwise noted, all bible verses are from the world english bible web. The wikipedia article on penal substitution states in its opening paragraph penal substitution sometimes, esp. Mar 26, 20 greg boyd outlines the penal substitution view of atonement and some of the problems this view creates. A refreshing contrast to the great number of lowcalorie atonement books on the market. The following are direct quotes from bruxy cavey in. Death is an unnatural intrusion into gods good world and not a part of his original intention for humankind. Similarly, david hilborn, in describing the recent controversy over penal substitution among british evangelicals, offers this characterization of penal substitution.
Try searching on jstor for other items related to this book. Penal means legal as in penal colony jesus was made under the law galatians 4. It is not t he purpose of thi s essay to explore or explain opposition to penal substitutionother essays in this series will deal with that matter. What emerges is a more complex, expansive, and fruitful understanding of the atonement and its. Next, heres a big long quote from an easilyaccessed online article in which he is critiquing a lecture by dr. Penal substitutionary atonement is a wholebible doctrine. Penal substitutionary atonement is the hope of sinners, the heart of the gospel, and the good news without which all other news regarding the cross is null and void. The heresy of penal substitution the morning offering.
Penal substitutionary atonement is the view that christ was a legal substitute for us on the cross and that he bore the penalty for our sins that is due to us. Historical reflections on substitutionary atonement fuller. So why is the ultimate sacrifice of christs penal substitution objectionable. The substitutionary atonement of jesus christ on the cross. The doctrine of atonement download ebook pdf, epub. Bruxy cavey teaching on gospel proclamation in the book of acts.
This work is designed to be an intermediate between introductory and academic treatment of penal substitutionary atonement. Wolfhart pannenbergs historical penal substitutionary atonement. Penal substitution was a way of talking about the cross with which i was. Penal substitutionary atonement god imputed the guilt of our sins to christ, and he, in our place, bore the punishment that we deserve. Penal substitutionary atonement has been the most difficult subject i have written on. Substitutionary atonement has been explicated in the classic paradigm of the early church fathers, namely the ransom theory, as well as in gustaf aulens demystified reformulation, the christus victor theory. Penal substitutionary atonement all we like sheep have gone astray. Making god bound by necessity the heretical doctrine of penal substitution was completely absent from the church for over 1,000 years, and was only introduced by anselm of canterbury in the eleventh century. M claren, the story we find ourselv es in furt her advent ures of a new kind of christi an san francisco. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. I do find both penal and substitutionary elements in a jesuscentered reading of scripture on the subject of atonement. In christian theology, jesus christ is the substitute, and the punishment he took at the cross was ours, based on our sin 1 peter 2. This compilation of hodges articles served as a useful resource for reformed churchesthen and nowand creates a deepened understanding of the atonement from the perspective of calvinism.
The book to end penal substitutionary atonement stephen d. Click download or read online button to get the doctrine of atonement book now. For those of you wondering, wright is a british new testament scholar who ranks among the top 2 or 3 most prolific, somewhat controversial, and influential churchmen on either side of the pond in a wide variety of. This is a shame, because as peter leithart recently reminds us, in both his classic jesusgod and man and his magnum opus, threevolume systematic theology pannenberg has one of. Holmes argues that we can, and should, continue to talk of the cross in penal substitutionary terms, if we. Penal substitution is a doctrine conscientious pastors and christian leaders must stay fresh on and be ready to winsomely answer when the attacks come.
Im not a theologian myself, so you wont get 10,000 smart words from me on this subject, although i understand the atonement to be about propitiation not mere expiation. Definite atonement is the centerpiece, says wilson. What is the penal substitutionary atonement theory. In recent years, a new series of articles and books has appeared which. The task which i have set myself in this lecture is to focus and explicate a belief which, by and large, is a distinguishing mark of the wordwide evangelical fraternity. Penal substitution is a theory of the atonement within christian theology, which argues that. Pdf penal substitutionary atonement in the early church fathers. The basic objective of this blog post is to demonstrate that there were components and more, of the penalsubstitutionary model of the atonement embraced by those in the ancient church and that this can be traced throughout the history of the church until it comes into its own in the works of anselm is not a difficult task. Can someone please recommend good, academic books on the orthodox view of the atonement. Responses to the alleged injustice of penal substitution. Penal means legal as in penalcolony jesus was made under the law galatians 4. In contrast, penal substitution is a legitimate and relevant representation of the. Why i have changed my mind about penal substitution. Understanding the longer history of penal substitutionary atonement and how it actually functions historically suggests several important reasons for why the doctrine is still important for us today.
It has seldom been given to any writer to work such a change in the history of thought as that wrought by. Chapter 5 provides a thorough survey of historical figures which demonstrates that substitutionary atonement has characterized all periods of church history. Mar 22, 2016 penal substitutionary atonement is the hope of sinners, the heart of the gospel, and the good news without which all other news regarding the cross is null and void. This is a highly important work with which any serious critic of penal substitution must reckon, and i commend it as a thorough and persuasive defense of a biblical understanding of the.
Belousek wants to examine penal substitutionary atonement and offer a new formulation in light of biblical, historical, and theological evidence. He previously taught church history at morling college, and is an adjunct faculty. Penal substitution in church history 201 3millard erickson, christi an theology grand rapids. An historical study of the three main types of the idea of. This was a full payment for sins, which satisfied both the wrath and the righteousness of god, so that he could forgive sinners without compromising his own holy standard. Jan 11, 2018 substitutionary atonement grounded in good trinitarian theology insists on the unity of purpose of the father and the son, since god was in christ reconciling the world to himself 2 cor. The cross of jesus was the centre of the message at summer camps, holiday bible clubs, and youth group talks. Jul 29, 2016 the basic objective of this blog post is to demonstrate that there were components and more, of the penal substitutionary model of the atonement embraced by those in the ancient church and that this can be traced throughout the history of the church until it comes into its own in the works of anselm is not a difficult task.
It doesnt get any more personal christianity today. This we call penal substitutionary atonement jesus reconciled sinners to god by being their substitute punishment. What emerges is a more complex, expansive, and fruitful understanding of the atonement and its significance for the christian faith today. The heart of substitutionary atonement substitutionary atonement rests on four concepts. Stephen sykes, the story of the atonement dlt 1997. I can recommend an astute essay on the current state of the atonement debate by jason hood, who is scholar in residence at christ umc in memphis.
Man is sinful and has broken gods law incurring the penalty of death. Kevin deyoung phd, university of leicester is senior pastor of christ covenant church in matthews, north carolina, board chairman of the gospel coalition, and assistant professor. Penal substitutionary atonement we do live at a time in history where many people identify penal substitutionary atonement theory as the gospel. C s lewis had a defective view of salvation and was an opponent of the substitutionary and penal view of the atonement. Oct 18, 2014 definite atonement is the centerpiece, says wilson. According to the doctrine of penal substitution, gods perfect justice demands some form of atonement for. The atonement began as a series of articles on the atonement which appeared in the presbyterian banner intended to correct the broad misrepresentation of the doctrine of the atonement. This compilation of hodges articles served as a useful resource for reformed churchesthen and nowand creates a deepened understanding of the atonement. An orthodox understanding of the atonement orthochristian. Mar 21, 2011 chapter 5 provides a thorough survey of historical figures which demonstrates that substitutionary atonement has characterized all periods of church history. Stott represents the view of substitutionary atonement with clarity in this classic book. Penal substitution simply means that jesus died to bear the penalty for my sins, hence penal, and. Penal substitution in perspective mcmaster university. Vlach assistant professor of theology recently, at least since t he ei ghteent hcent ury l iber ali sm gained a plac e in pro testant ism, the penalsubstitution view of christs atonement has come under attack.
Penal substitutionary atonement is a theory which attempts to explain the meaning and purpose of christs death, how jesus death saves and what it means for the world. Apr 12, 2010 i can recommend an astute essay on the current state of the atonement debate by jason hood, who is scholar in residence at christ umc in memphis. Christus victor by gustaf aulen, perspectives on the extent of the atonement. Medical substitutionary atonement in irenaeus of lyons. For many, commitment to penal substitutionary atonement psa has eroded. The three middle points unconditional election, definite atonement, and irresistible grace demonstrate how the persons of the godhead work together inseparably in our salvation. Penal substitutionary atonement and narrative theology p. The doctrine of atonement download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. It proceeds from theology proper, derives from the promise of a headcrushing deliverer in genesis 3, and culminates in the eschatological dwelling of the bloodbought people of god in the new jerusalem. The book to end penal substitutionary atonement stephen. Theologian oliver crisp explores the meaning of the cross and the various ways that the death of jesus has been interpreted in the churchs historyfrom ransom theory in the early church to penal substitutionary theory to more recent feminist critiques. Holmes argues that we can, and should, continue to talk of the cross in penal substitutionary terms, if we understand this as one of many complimentary descriptions of the. Is penal substitution unjust scholarly reasonable faith.
Substitution, claim that penal substitutionary theory stretches back to. As a church leader, he had probably used the contents of this book with. Jun 27, 2017 i do find both penal and substitutionary elements in a jesuscentered reading of scripture on the subject of atonement. Consider recommending these five books on this precious doctrine to your people. Pdf, epub, and kindle files will be sent to this email address. Review copy courtesy of paternosterauthentic books it seems that not too many theologians feel just as comfortable writing about isaiah and jonah as they do anselm, aquinas, doctor who, kierkegaard, coleridge and matt. This false teaching of penal substitution was ultimately developed as seen in the west today, by 16thcentury reformers, but is a doctrine that has never been accepted.
This book represents a standard reformed view of penal substitutionary atonement. He absorbed in his person gods righteous wrath against us, because of our sin, that we might be free from sin and its penalty and liberated to enjoy such a person forever. Unfortunately, it is precisely the conviction that the innocent ought not to be punished that lies behind the claim that penal substitutionary atonement theories are unjust and immoral. Why i have changed my mind about penal substitution i was brought up in the kind of evangelical church that drummed into us as children that jesus died to save us from our sins. Substitutionary atonement grounded in good trinitarian theology insists on the unity of purpose of the father and the son, since god was in christ reconciling the world to himself 2 cor. First, it was arguably the dominant view in the century following the apostles and in continuity with their teaching.
Since ones belief about the atonement is bound up with ones belief. We must inform the criticism of a penal substitutionary doctrine of the atonement by noting that the bible everywhere views human death not as a natural but as a penal event. Colin greene, is the message of the cross good news for. Penal substitution evangelical theological society.
1075 1311 401 550 867 960 1216 1094 536 519 632 575 947 520 299 982 60 1117 329 1536 1097 523 330 1193 256 1055 727 292 826 1126 1316 590 880 736 1200 982 627 286 310 151 761 633 1057 1015 295 1228 631 146